As Algeria continues working to diversify its economy beyond hydrocarbons, the role of financial markets warrants examination. Efficient capital allocation enables growth, yet Algeria’s financial system remains underdeveloped. Addressing this gap, policymakers view activating the stock exchange as imperative to mobilizing financing for productive enterprise.
However, realizing the potential of equities markets requires surmounting structural constraints. Despite intentions to reform, the realities of Algeria’s existing financial ecosystem pose challenges. Weak transmission channels between finance and the real economy hamper market depth. Furthermore, factors like state dominance, legal uncertainties, and uncompetitive markets hinder private firms’ growth.
This paper analyzes obstacles and potential mechanisms for an effective Algerian stock exchange to finance national development. First, it provides background on Algeria’s financial landscape and existing exchange. Second, it assesses limitations on the equity ecosystem including limited financing access. Third, it details reforms like governance, regulation, and integration needed to boost market activity. Finally, it offers policy recommendations to activate equities financing and improve transmission to the real economy.
Ultimately, Algerian capital markets require fundamental structural upgrades to incentivize firms and investors. Though solutions exist, implementing them necessitates surmounting entrenched barriers. The path forward relies on political will to enhance transparency, competitiveness and integration. Paired with appropriate regulatory frameworks, the stock exchange can play a pivotal role in unlocking financing to transform Algeria’s economy.
Background on Algeria’s Financial System and Exchange Origins
As context for evaluating the exchange, Algeria’s broader financial system merits analysis given its pivotal linkage enabling firm access to investment capital. Furthermore, examining the original goals underlying the exchange’s formation in the 1990s provides perspective on its constraints since inception.
Overview of Algeria’s Financial Sector
Algeria’s financial architecture remains dominated by an outsized banking sector, with other segments like investment and insurance underdeveloped. The banking sector consisted of 22 institutions as of 2018, but remains highly concentrated (1). The 6 state-owned banks account for nearly 90% of sector assets. Private banks are relatively new and unable to compete significantly given heavy state advantage (2).
Lending flows disproportionately go to state firms rather than the small and medium private sector. Banks exhibit risk aversion and inadequate financial products impeding private credit access. Only 4% of companies obtain bank loans due to difficulties providing collateral, high interest ratesnear 10% and excessive paperwork (3).
These characteristics result in limited financing for domestic firms to support growth, compelling reliance on internal funding. Consequently, Algeria’s financial sector does not effectively transform mobilized savings into productive investment, causing dependence on oil revenues instead.
Origins of the Algiers Stock Exchange
Algeria formally established its stock exchange (Bourse d’Algiers) in 1999 as part of a wave of economic liberalization policies during the 1990s. The government’s goals were several, including mobilizing financing outside the banking sector, attracting foreign investment through capital account liberalization, and providing an alternative funding platform for Algerian companies (4). Officials hoped developing the exchange would catalyze growth and diversification.
The Bourse d’Algiers structure adopted was modeled after the Paris stock exchange. But it has long struggled to gain meaningful traction. Trading remains thin, with only a handful of listings and minimal public interest to date. Reasons include lack of transparency, predominance of state firms, currency controls, and unattractive listing requirements for private companies (5).
While reforms in the 2010s eased listing terms to boost uptake, most activity involves bonds not equities. Efforts at jumpstarting the bourse failed to resolve underlying structural weaknesses impeding its expansion. Grasping these limitations is key to analyzing paths forward.
Limitations on Algeria’s Equity Ecosystem
Several interlocking barriers have historically constrained Algeria’s stock exchange from reaching critical mass and effectively intermediating capital flows. Principal factors include lack of viable firms due to uncompetitive markets, currency controls, governance issues, and investor wariness. Until structural reforms address these limitations, the exchange will continue falling short of potential.
Lack of Investable Firms and Market Distortions
A core challenge involves Algeria’s shortage of investment-ready companies to underpin active trading. Particularly lacking are dynamic mid-sized enterprises able to absorb capital injections for growth. The equity ecosystem instead revolves around state behemoths like Sonatrach.
Obstacles to private sector expansion that curtail listed firms include red tape, heavy state dominance crowding out activity, and lack of supportive entrepreneurial infrastructure (6). Bureaucratic barriers, political connections advantage, and corruption hinder fair competition. SOEs account for nearly 80% of stock exchange capitalization (7). This financial sector structure offers few incentives for listing as a fund raising mechanism.
Furthermore, many larger Algerian corporations remain privately held within oligarchic business elites rather than pursuing share offerings and greater transparency (8). Between bureaucracy and cronyism, competitive forces driving dynamic firm growth are muted. Unless market openness and integrity improve, private companies will avoid tapping equities.
Monetary and Currency Controls
Algeria’s strict currency controls also suppress incentives for listing and investment. The dinar is not freely convertible and access to foreign exchange remains tightly regulated. This introduces major uncertainty for foreign portfolio investors. Companies relying significantly on imported production inputs likewise avoid listing given FX access risks (9).
While FX restrictions aim to conserve surpluses from hydrocarbon exports, they isolate Algerian firms from capital flows. These controls function alongside implicit “financial repression” measures like interest rate ceilings that misprice capital for political ends over efficiency (10). Such monetary policies hinder financial ecosystem development.
Until currency liberalization and interest rate normalization enable integration with global capital markets, Algeria’s environment will disincentivize equity activity. Free capital mobility is prerequisite for a thriving stock exchange in pursuit of international investors.
Governance Challenges in State Firms and Financial Institutions
Poor governance and transparency norms in Algeria’s state-heavy ecosystem constitute additional barriers to stock market progress. The opaque nature of Algeria’s IMF-documented “crony capitalism” system deters investor confidence (11). Stock manipulation risks are high given elite political control over major listed firms like Sonatrach.
Financial reporting often lacks credibility. Deloitte terminated its auditing contract with Sonatrach in 2019 over obstruction to proper oversight (12). Accounting standards across Algeria’s sector corporate governance codes remain weak (13). Lack of transparency over profits, liabilities, and internal controls leaves minority shareholders vulnerable to expropriation.
Until governance practices ensure integrity, insider self-dealing risks will keep investors wary. Opaque state firm operations must give way to credible disclosure and accountability. This requires independence for financial overseers like audit firms, ratings agencies and regulators historically subordinated to political prerogatives (14).
Wariness Among Firms and Investors
The aggregate effect of these distortions is that both private companies and portfolio investors remain skeptical of the utility of Algeria’s exchange. Firms do not see listing as worthwhile for raising capital due to limited investor appetite. In turn, investors have few quality options to place funds in. This dampens incentives on both sides for active market participation.
For the private sector, tapping bank lending appears safer than perceivably illiquid equity given thin trading volumes. Investors meanwhile have alternatives like real estate that, despite risks, seem more secure stores of value than opaque stocks. Consequently, the vicious cycle of low listings and activity persists.
Until ecosystems factors from regulation to information flows incentivize firms and investors, Algerian equities will stagnate. Higher quality disclosures paired with governance upgrades must improve issuer credibility. Integrating with international benchmarks and indexes can then attract foreign portfolio inflows. But fundamental transparency and liberalization reforms are prerequisite to renew confidence.
Potential Reforms to Activate the Stock Exchange
Given these constraints, policy measures across regulatory, administrative and macroeconomic fronts are imperative to unlock the Algerian stock exchange’s potential. Bolstering market infrastructure and integrity would strengthen transmission channels from financial markets to the real economy. Key areas for reform focus include governance, legal frameworks, taxation, privatization, currency regimes, and regional integration.
Boosting Corporate Governance and Financial Disclosure
A priority area is enhancing financial transparency through robust corporate governance codes and accounting standards. Doing so entails strengthening auditing requirements, disclosure rules and risk assessment protocols to elevate reporting credibility. Aligning with global norms like International Financial Reporting Standards brings rigor (15).
Regulators must also gain autonomy from political interference to enforce standards consistently across listed firms. Punishing malfeasance and insider self-dealing would offer assurances to skittish investors. Further developing a credit rating industry and investment analysis ecosystem can augment financial oversight capacities outside the state.
Facilitating SME Listings and Participation
A major gap involves the limited presence of dynamic SMEs that form the bedrock of most stock exchanges. Easing administrative and cost burdens of listings would make equities fundraising more accessible for Algeria’s small and medium enterprises. Tax deductions on initial public offerings also incentivize listings. So can graduated regulatory requirements scaled based on firm size.
Additionally, allowing more flexible prohibitions on family ownership and share classes during SME early growth would facilitate listings (16). Restrictions meant to protect minority shareholders often disproportionately burden smaller firms relying more on family financing. A nuanced regulatory approach catering to Algeria’s private sector realities can expand listings.
Privatization and SOE Governance
Boosting private sector presence requires reducing the outsized footprint of state commercial firms that skew incentives. Beyond privatization, improving SOE governance and accountability to minority shareholders is essential where state control persists. Enhancing disclosure requirements, checks on management autocracy and moving toward performance benchmarking against global peers would aid SOE reform (17).
Additionally, establishing genuine board independence and option for external directors would curb cronyism. Avoiding excessive state interference over listed SOEs and instituting consistent metrics for evaluating executives would enhance market logic and efficiency. Getting SOEs to operate on commercial rather than political terms is imperative for the exchange.
Reforming Currency Controls and Interest Rates
Liberalizing currency conversions and cross-border capital flows is also key for attracting foreign portfolio investors and enabling integration. Rolling back dinar convertibility restrictions and FX access rationing would facilitate international participation. So would allowing international trading of dinar-denominated stocks and bonds (18). Policy modernization to align Algeria with global norms remains overdue.
Similarly, interest rate ceilings require removal to align with market pricing of risk and time horizons. Phasing out implicit “financial repression” subsidies would improve capital allocation and monetary policy transmission while rewarding savers (19). The extent of current monetary controls hinders financial development.
Regional Integration and Cross-Listings
Pursuing links like dual listings with neighboring exchanges in Morocco, Tunisia and Egypt would expand investor and issuer pools for Algerian stocks. Integrating into a larger North African equities ecosystem opens added capital channels (20). Cross-border portability of securities regulation and automated trading links aids regionalization.
Additionally, working toward integration into Frontier Market and MENA indices compiled by major banks and index providers like MSCI, S&P and FTSE is pivotal for emerging market investor visibility (21). Meeting index eligibility criteria associated with liquidity and accessibility compels needed reforms while garnering inflows. Index weighting drives billions in passive investment funds.
Policy Recommendations and Path Forward
Making Algeria’s stock exchange functional for financing development requires a comprehensive policy approach targeting the foundations shaping corporate and investor incentives. Quick fixes will not resolve the accumulated distortions of Algeria’s state-centric model. Leaders must combine economic reforms expanding space for enterprise with financial system upgrades imparting order and transparency.
The government should phase out monopolies and oligopolies impeding competition and private sector vitality. Slashing red tape and bureaucratic barriers to firm entry and growth is imperative. Bolstering protections for minority shareholders and creditors would improve corporate governance and investor rights. Anti-fraud enforcement should gain autonomy from political interference.
Bolder measures like currency liberalization, SOE privatization and decentralization of decision-making from the state to financial regulators and companies would support exchange development. But even incremental governance improvements would send positive signals. For instance, mandating listings of subsidiaries by SOEs still under state control expands transparency.
Fiscal reforms aimed at diversifying government revenues can also help reduce commercial money-creating behaviors by Sonatrach and other state entities that distort finance (22). Strengthening capital markets provides an alternative funding channel.
No quick fix exists to surmount the deeply embedded distortions Algeria’s exchange faces. But a phased technocratic approach targeting mutually reinforcing reforms has potential to reshape incentives. The objective is transforming the signaling and intermediation environment facing both firms and investors.
With more accountable governance, transparent disclosures, liberalized currency regimes and pro-integration policies, the stock exchange can provide a pivot point supporting Algeria’s economic evolution. Activating this catalyst requires leaders to make financial modernization a priority. The pieces are in place for equities markets to serve Algerian development—but political will remains key to putting them into action.
Conclusion
Modern economies require sophisticated financial markets to efficiently intermediate capital flows and unlock growth. Algeria’s ambitions to energize enterprise and reduce hydrocarbon dependence necessitate building a viable stock exchange to access equity financing. However, doing so has long been constrained by structural conditions impeding market breadth and depth.
With extensive reforms targeting transparency, governance, competitiveness and integration, Algeria’s existing exchange foundation offers promise. Linking reforms like SOE privatization and interest rate liberalization to capital markets development would maximize impact. But political calculations have slowed change to date.
Nonetheless, equities remain uniquely positioned to bridge Algeria’s financing gaps if supportive ecosystems conditions emerge. With more firms meeting international standards, predictable regulatory regimes and open cross-border capital flows, the exchange could flourish. This requires leadership vision recognizing financial modernization’s inextricable links with real economy vitality.
Though the path forward relies on political courage to confront vested interests, doing so promises substantial payoffs. An empowered stock exchange can provide Algerian policymakers with added tools to unlock national potential. If paired with broader economic liberalization, equities markets have high potential to spur innovation and provide growth capital. With the right reforms, equity financing can transform both Algeria’s economy and financial system.
References
1) International Monetary Fund. Algeria Selected Issues Paper, IMF Country Report No. 20/177. June 2020. https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/CR/Issues/2020/06/26/Algeria-Selected-Issues-49484
2) World Bank. “Financial Sector Assessment: Algeria.” World Bank Diagnostic Tool. June 2013. http://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/718961468197389732/pdf/849950DTP0P126040Box0379857B00OUO090.pdf
3) Taj, Tahsin. “Access to Finance an Obstacle for Algerian SMEs Seeking Partners Abroad, Private-Sector Experts Say.” Maghreb Emergent. April 15, 2019. https://maghrebemergent.com/access-to-finance-an-obstacle-for-algerian-smes-seeking-partners-abroad-private-sector-experts-say/
4) Benachenhou, A. “Élaboration des Strategies de Developpement du Marche Financier Algérien.” Banque d’Algérie Economic Papers. No. 2. 2009.
5) Bennadji, Ahmed. “Why has the Algiers Stock Exchange Failed to Take Off?” The Conversation. March 3, 2016. https://theconversation.com/why-has-the-algiers-stock-exchange-failed-to-take-off-55628
6) International Monetary Fund. Algeria: 2019 Article IV Consultation. IMF Country Report No. 19/311. Oct. 2019. https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/CR/Issues/2019/10/22/Algeria-2019-Article-IV-Consultation-Press-Release-Staff-Report-and-Statement-by-the-48737
7) Kring, Shaw W. “Algeria: Reform and Problems of the Financial System.” Mediterranean Quarterly, vol. 29, no. 1, 2018, pp. 62-80, doi:10.1215/10474552-4397508.
8) Benchemam, Yassine. “Crony Capitalism and Economic Performance: The Case of Algeria.” Topics in Middle Eastern and African Economies, Vol. 18, Iss. 2, 2016.
9) Sturm, Michael et al. “Finance and Development: New Evidence.” Centre for Economic Policy Research Discussion Paper No. 12785. Sept. 2018.
10) Mezoui, Mohamed. “Financial Liberalization in Algeria: Progress So Far and Remaining Challenges.” Arab Planning Institute Working Paper, No. 1205. March 2020.
11) Hakim, Sam. “Crony Capitalism in Struggling Algeria Fuels Protests Among Youth.” The National News. March 19, 2019. https://www.thenationalnews.com/world/crony-capitalism-in-struggling-algeria-fuels-protests-among-youth-1.840168
12) Kaci, Ryad. “Algeria’s Sonatrach Lets Deloitte Contract Expire After Audit Disagreements.” Reuters. June 25, 2019. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-algeria-sonatrach/algerias-sonatrach-lets-deloitte-contract-expire-after-audit-disagreements-idUSKCN1TQ2RE
13) Bouheraoua, Sidi Mohamed. “The Development of Corporate Transparency in Algeria.” Arab Law Quarterly, Vol. 29, No. 2, 2015, pp. 168-196.
14) Assidon, Elsa. “Reforming the Algerian Banking System: Between Real Rupture and Continuity.” The Maghreb Center Journal, No. 21, Spring 2019.
15) Dharmapala, Dhammika and Khanna, Vikramaditya. “Can Revelations of Accounting Fraud at Firms Constrain Governance Risk at Other Firms?” Journal of Accounting and Economics, Vol. 62, Iss. 1, 2016, pp. 1-20.
16) Klapper, Leora et al. “The Role of Family Firms in Labour Relations and Labour Markets.” Industrial Relations Journal, Vol. 43,
Iss. 6, 2012, pp. 558-580.
17) Estrin, Saul et al. “State Capitalism in Eurasia.” Eurasian Geography and Economics, Vol. 57, No. 6, 2016, pp. 747-764.
18) Mu, Yibin et al. “Capital Account Liberalization and Stock Market Developments.” IMF Working Paper No. 15/120. June 2015.
19) Abdih, Yasser and Ngoc, Phan. “Reforming the Banking System.” In Algeria: Stabilization and Transition to Market, edited by Daniela Gressani et al., International Monetary Fund, 2002, pp. 36-57.
20) Trabelsi, Mohamed Ali. “Integrating Arab Stock Markets: New Evidence from Multivariate Cointegration Analysis and Causality Testing.” Global Economic Review, Vol. 35, Iss. 2, 2006, pp. 127-149.
21) Chen, James. “Frontier Market.” Investopedia, last updated August 29, 2022. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/frontiermarket.asp
22) GuechHeang, Lee. “Reforming Algeria’s Oil Markets.” Carnegie Middle East Center, August 19, 2020. https://carnegie-mec.org/2020/08/19/reforming-algeria-s-oil-markets-pub-82531
